Why Bill Hybels Serves as a Warning to Pastors
- Brother Pastor
- Sep 16, 2022
- 5 min read
Updated: Mar 13
The fall of Bill Hybels demands the attention of pastors everywhere. Let me be clear—I am not rejoicing in the downfall of one of God’s beloved.
Yet, he became the archetype of a church leader who loves the world, preaches innovation, and drifts from God. Anyone celebrating this should be ashamed and cannot claim to follow Jesus Christ.
Still, I give thanks that this man, who misled millions worldwide, can no longer do so. The Lord “killed the ministry to save the soul,” and for that, I glory in Him.
It might appear that Hybels fell due to a few indiscretions, but the truth is simpler: he peddled a false “leadership” gospel, and God removed him. In Galatians, Paul opens with a Spirit-led greeting, and in chapter 1, he swiftly addresses his purpose.
Far be it from me to suggest there was only one aim, but Paul first confronts the church’s abandonment of the gospel. Similarly, in Revelation 2:4, we read, “Thou hast left thy first love.” This is what the Galatians did—forsaking the sound doctrine they once embraced.
Hybels mirrored this by chasing popularity over God’s call.
False teachings persist today—Mormonism, Hinduism, Buddhism, Jehovah’s Witnesses, Islam—and yet, the most damaging distortions arise within the church itself. Paul warns in Galatians 1:8-9, “If I or an angel from heaven preach any other gospel than what we have preached, let them be accursed.”
He repeats it for emphasis, underscoring that his gospel alone is true, and all else—temporal or eternal—is cursed. Hybels’ “leadership gospel” aligns with the “prosperity gospel,” two sides of the same coin: one worships power and self, the other money.
Prosperity doctrine claims God ordains material wealth as a sign and source of faith, ignoring Jesus’ words: “It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God” (Matthew 19:24).
If God intended all His people to be materially rich, how do we explain Lazarus the beggar or Jesus saying, “The Son of Man has nowhere to lay His head” (Matthew 8:20)? In the story of the rich young ruler, Jesus instructs, “Sell all you have, give to the poor, and follow Me” (Matthew 19:21), yet the man walks away sad, bound by his wealth.
These passages reveal that material riches often distract from Christ. Hybels compromised truth for prestige, leaving him with neither.
Many modern churches prioritize “butts in the pews” over souls in Heaven, diluting the gospel into something unbiblical. Jesus Himself said, “I came not to bring peace, but a sword” (Matthew 10:34), to divide, not unite, through the unyielding truth.
In pursuit of growth, churches replace biblical offices like deacons with “care ministries.” While such ministries have value, supplanting God-ordained roles is indefensible. Pastors and leaders lack authority to nullify what God established.
Hybels’ Willow Creek Leadership Summit epitomized this error, appealing to worldly figures like General Colin Powell to train church leaders.
Powell, a master of carnal warfare, was unfit to guide God’s shepherds. Scripture declares, “The weapons of our warfare are not carnal” (2 Corinthians 10:4), yet Hybels blended worldly strategies into the church, crafting a false “leadership gospel” that mocked the true gospel of Christ.
This blending of the secular and the sacred is not merely a misstep—it’s a betrayal of the church’s calling. Hybels’ obsession with false church leadership techniques borrowed from corporate boardrooms and military playbooks reveals a deeper flaw: a lack of trust in the sufficiency of Scripture.
The Bible is not a supplementary resource to be enhanced by human wisdom; it is the living Word of God, “sharper than any two-edged sword” (Hebrews 4:12), capable of equipping every believer for every good work (2 Timothy 3:16-17).
When pastors turn to worldly gurus for guidance, they implicitly declare that God’s Word is inadequate—a dangerous lie that Hybels embraced to his peril.
Consider the early church in Acts. Did Peter consult Roman generals to grow the flock? Did Paul study Greek philosophers to refine his preaching? No—they relied on the Holy Spirit and the unchanging truth of Christ crucified.
Hybels, by contrast, built a ministry on sand, chasing relevance over reverence. His summits trained leaders to prioritize efficiency over faithfulness, charisma over character, and numbers over discipleship. The result was a hollow empire, impressive to the world but brittle before God.
The collapse of Bill Hybels’ ministry stands as a blazing siren for every pastor: compromise with the world invites divine judgment. His “leadership gospel” seduced the church with promises of power and relevance, yet it led only to ruin.
Pastors must reject the lure of innovation that dilutes God’s truth, for the stakes are eternal. Hybels’ fall proves that God will not tolerate shepherds who lead His flock astray with counterfeit doctrines—whether draped in prosperity or cloaked in leadership jargon.
The church must return to its first love, preaching the unadulterated gospel, lest it too be stripped bare by the hand of a holy God.
This warning extends beyond Hybels to every congregation and leader today. The church is not a business to be managed, nor a stage for self-aggrandizement. It is the bride of Christ, purchased with His blood, entrusted with His message.
When pastors trade that message for worldly applause, they invite the same fate as Hybels—a ministry reduced to ashes, a legacy of warning rather than blessing. The prophet Jeremiah spoke to a wayward Israel, “My people have committed two evils: they have forsaken Me, the fountain of living waters, and hewed out cisterns for themselves, broken cisterns that can hold no water” (Jeremiah 2:13).
Hybels’ broken cisterns held no living water, and neither will those of any pastor who follows his path.
Let this be a clarion call: the days of blending worldly wisdom with sacred truth are over. Pastors, take heed—God’s Word is not a suggestion but a command, and He will purify His church, with or without our consent.
Hybels’ legacy is a tombstone etched with a warning: chase prestige, and you will lose both it and your soul. Stand firm on the rock of Christ, for only there will the church endure the storms ahead. The time for half-measures is gone; the gospel demands all, and God will accept nothing less.
So let every pastor examine their heart and their pulpit. Are you preaching Christ, or are you preaching yourself? Are you shepherding souls, or are you building a brand? The Lord is patient, but He is not mocked (Galatians 6:7). Hybels’ fall is not the end of the story—it’s a prelude to the greater reckoning God has promised.
Return to the cross, proclaim the truth, and trust in the One who holds the church in His hands. For in the end, it is not the size of the flock that matters, but the faithfulness of the shepherd—and the holiness of the God he serves.
Comments